Vol. I, No. 4
Covering 23 September - 6 October 2024
Monday, October 7, 2024
Late edition · A Relentless publication
All the fortnight that mattered, in technology and in the world, read next to what we were building at the time.
We looked it up so that you could look up.
THE MIDDLE EAST

A year after October 7, the war becomes the regional inferno everyone feared

Israel killed Hezbollah's leader, invaded Lebanon, and absorbed a barrage of 180 Iranian missiles. The conflict that began with a massacre in Israel is now a multi-front war drawing in the whole region, just as it was warned it would.

The war reached the escalation it had threatened for a year. On September 27 an Israeli airstrike killed Hassan Nasrallah, the secretary-general of Hezbollah who had led the Lebanese movement for over three decades and made it the most powerful non-state armed force in the world, in a massive strike on its underground headquarters in Beirut. Days later, on October 1, Israel launched a ground invasion of southern Lebanon, and Iran responded with its largest-ever direct assault on Israel, some 180 ballistic missiles fired at once, most intercepted but a stark escalation from the more contained exchange of strikes the two countries traded in April. Lebanon reeled under Israeli bombardment that killed hundreds and displaced a million people in a fortnight; Israel vowed to strike Iran in return; and the region held its breath for what an Israeli retaliation against Iran, and Iran's response to that, might unleash.

The anniversary of the October 7 massacre that began it all fell in the middle of the escalation, a year to the day since Hamas killed 1,200 Israelis and took 250 hostages, some 100 of whom, alive and dead, remain held in Gaza, where the war has killed more than 40,000 Palestinians and reduced much of the territory to rubble. A year on, none of the war's aims had been achieved and all of its horrors had multiplied: Hamas not destroyed, the hostages not freed, and now Hezbollah decapitated, Lebanon aflame, and Iran and Israel trading direct blows for the first time in history. The conflict that began with a single terrible day had become, over a year, the regional war that every warning had described, climbing the ladder rung by rung, each step called proportionate, each response demanding the next, toward a precipice no one could quite see the bottom of.

AMERICA

A hurricane drowns the mountains, and a port strike squeezes the economy

Hurricane Helene, which made landfall in Florida on September 26, drove hundreds of miles inland to deliver its worst devastation not on the coast but in the mountains of western North Carolina, where catastrophic flooding swept away whole towns, cut off the city of Asheville, and killed more than 230 people across the southeast, the deadliest US hurricane since Katrina. The mountain communities, thought safe by their distance from the sea, were unprepared for a flood no living resident had imagined. Days later, on October 1, dockworkers at ports along the US East and Gulf coasts went on strike for the first time in nearly 50 years, threatening to choke a huge share of the nation's imports weeks before an election, until a tentative deal suspended it after three days.

IN BRIEF

The running mates debate; a machine's milestones

The vice-presidential candidates, Tim Walz and JD Vance, debated on October 1 in a notably civil exchange that stood out for its calm in a savage campaign, though it was unlikely to move a race consumed by the top of the tickets. And the artificial-intelligence field marked steady advances amid the geopolitical storm, its models growing more capable at reasoning and its costs, for now, still soaring, as the industry awaited the returns that would justify a year of frenzied spending.

The Column

Before you say "both" this week

You will go to a vigil, or write a message, or stand in a kitchen arguing, and the fairest word you know will offer itself. Take it. But know that the word holds two jobs, and that one of them tells the truth while the other buries it.

This week you will mark a year. Perhaps at a vigil, perhaps in a carefully drafted post, perhaps in a hard conversation with someone you love who sees this war from the other shore. And somewhere in your sentence the word "both" is already waiting, because you are a decent person and it is the most decent-sounding word the year has produced. Both peoples. Both griefs. Both entitled to safety. I am not writing to confiscate it. I am asking you to look at what you load onto it before you let it leave your mouth.

Use it first where it carries the whole truth. When you light a candle for the 1,200 killed on 7 October and for the hostages still underground, and in the same breath for the more than 40,000 Palestinians killed since, entire families struck from the registry, say both, and plant your feet. If anyone, from any side, asks you to ration your mourning, to grieve one child at full price and the other at a discount, refuse them. The Israeli child and the Gazan child are equally, infinitely grievable, and a conscience that can weep for one while auditing the other has failed before the politics even begins. At the level of grief, "both" is not a hedge. It is the floor, and you should hold it against all comers; I will be beside you.

Now watch the same word climb a level, out of grief and into power, because that is where it goes wrong, and it goes wrong this very fortnight. You have heard the sentences: violence on both sides, restraint from both sides, both must step back. Before you repeat them, make the sentences answer you. Does each side possess an air force? Does one side control the other's borders, water, electricity, airspace and coastline, or do they control each other's? Which of the two is occupied, and which operates the occupation? Is each shielded at the Security Council by a superpower's veto? In the past two weeks one party to this "both" assassinated the leader of a militia in a neighbouring country, invaded that country, and absorbed a barrage of 180 ballistic missiles from a third state, while a million people fled their homes in Lebanon. If your answers refuse to come out symmetric, then the symmetric word is not describing the situation. It is dressing it, and the dress is doing work: a sentence that distributes responsibility equally across an unequal field has quietly taken the stronger side while borrowing the voice of neutrality.

You may want to stop me here with what you know to be true: that Hamas committed an atrocity a year ago this week, that rockets and massacres are not figments, that weakness acquits no one. Keep all of it. I say it here without qualification; a crime does not need symmetrical power behind it to be a crime. What I am asking you to surrender is one thing only, and it is harder than it sounds: the idea that counting power is the same as picking a team. Naming who holds the guns, the gates, the water and the veto is not partisanship. It is the arithmetic that any honest use of "both" has to survive, and the version of the word that cannot survive it was never fairness. It was anaesthesia, administered in fairness's voice, and in this conflict you have heard it administered more times than you can count.

So this week, one discipline, each time the word rises. Ask your own sentence a single question first: is this about grief, or about power? If grief, say both, say it at full volume, and defend it like something sacred, because it is. If power, put the word down and do the counting instead, holding by holding, name by name. You will find the two vocabularies cannot share a sentence without one of them lying. Keeping them apart is unglamorous work, and the fortnight just past guarantees you more of it: a million people are on the roads of Lebanon tonight, the barrages will be answered, the answers will have anniversaries, and at each of them the word will rise in you again, offering to do both jobs in one breath. Make it choose before it leaves your mouth, at the vigil, in the post, in the kitchen, for as long as this war keeps filling the week with its dead.

The Back Page

After the water

A flood is photographed at its crest. The pictures from western North Carolina that the world will remember are of brown water where towns should be: the Swannanoa and the French Broad out of their banks, houses riding the current whole, the interstates snapped, Asheville sealed off from every direction at once. But the crest lasted an afternoon, and what Hurricane Helene actually left in the mountains, when the rivers went back into their beds, is mud. Feet of it, in places, a dense grey river silt lying through living rooms and surgeries and school gymnasiums, packed into car engines and pianos and the workings of the water plant, filling the basements of businesses that had reopened after the pandemic on their last reserves of stubbornness. And mud, unlike floodwater, does not recede. Every cubic foot of it has to be lifted, by somebody, with a shovel, and carried somewhere else; every soaked wall has to be cut out before the mould takes it; every well flushed, every bridge footing inspected, every mile of washed-out mountain road rebuilt against a slope that is itself no longer trustworthy. The water's work in the valleys took one night. Undoing it will take a calendar of seasons, and it will be done mostly out of the pictures, by residents and line crews and church kitchens and strangers with chainsaws, in the slow weeks after the satellite vans have moved on to newer water. More than 230 people died across the southeast, and the mourning will have its anniversaries. The living, in the valleys, have been handed a different unit of time: not the night the river rose, but the year of the mud.