Vol. I, No. 3
Covering 9 September - 22 September 2024
Monday, September 23, 2024
Late edition · A Relentless publication❀
All the fortnight that mattered, in technology and in the world, read next to what we were building at the time.
All the news that survived a second reading.
LEBANON

Thousands of pagers explode at once, and a new and terrifying kind of warfare is born

Across Lebanon, in pockets and on belts, the pagers Hezbollah used to evade surveillance detonated in the same instant, then the walkie-talkies the next day. Thousands were maimed. It was an attack on the supply chain itself, and it changes what a device in your pocket means.

In an operation without real precedent, thousands of pagers carried by members of the Lebanese militant group Hezbollah exploded simultaneously across the country on September 17, followed the next day by a wave of exploding walkie-talkies, killing dozens, including children, and wounding thousands, many maimed in the hands, face and eyes. The devices, it emerged, had been compromised at the source: Israel, by the near-universal assessment, had infiltrated Hezbollah's supply chain, planting small charges in the pagers before they ever reached their users, and then triggered them all at once. Hezbollah had switched to pagers expressly to avoid the phone surveillance it knew Israel excelled at; the low-tech choice became the trap. The group was left reeling, its communications shattered, its members afraid to touch their own equipment, and days later Israel escalated with heavy airstrikes on Lebanon, and the border fire Hezbollah had kept up in support of Hamas since the Gaza war began last October lurched closer to the wider war so long feared.

The military ingenuity was undeniable, and so was the horror, thousands of casualties from devices that detonated in markets, homes and hospitals, wherever their owners happened to be, with no way to know who was holding one. But beyond the immediate carnage and the escalation it drove, the operation announced something with implications far past this war, and it is the thing that should unsettle everyone: an attack not on a network or a system but on the physical supply chain, on the devices themselves, compromised in the factory or the warehouse before they were ever switched on. It is a demonstration, at horrifying scale, that the objects we carry and trust can be turned against us at their point of origin, and that the long, opaque, global supply chains that produce all our devices are a vulnerability no firewall can patch.

THE ECONOMY

The Fed cuts rates by half a point, and the long tightening ends

The Federal Reserve cut interest rates on September 18 by a bold half a percentage point, its first cut in over four years, formally ending the aggressive tightening campaign it began in early 2022 and signalling that the fight against inflation had been substantially won without the recession nearly everyone had forecast. The larger-than-usual cut, and the projections of more to come, amounted to the Fed's declaration that the economy had achieved the fabled soft landing, inflation tamed, unemployment still low, growth intact. Markets, which had waited for this moment for the better part of two years, welcomed it, and the frozen housing market, and every borrower who had suffered under the highest rates in a generation, felt the first real loosening in years.

IN BRIEF

A debate, an endorsement, a second attempt; a machine that pauses to think

Kamala Harris was widely judged to have bested Donald Trump in their September 10 debate, her first against him since she replaced Joe Biden at the top of the Democratic ticket in July, provoking him into defensive rants, including a bizarre amplification of a false rumour about immigrants eating pets, and drew, minutes after it ended, an endorsement from Taylor Swift. Days later, on September 15, a man with a rifle was discovered near a Florida golf course where Trump was playing, a second apparent assassination attempt in two months, foiled before a shot was fired at the former president. And OpenAI released a new model, o1, designed to pause and "reason" through problems step by step before answering, a shift from instant response toward deliberate thought that its makers called a new paradigm.

The Column

Working the pager problem, and failing

Once it is known that ordinary objects can be weaponised somewhere between factory and pocket, what is the sane response? Three roads suggest themselves. This column walks each of them as far as it goes, which turns out to be not far, and ends where it honestly ends: in the open.

Here is what can be stated. On 17 September, pagers detonated in pockets and hands across Lebanon; on the 18th, walkie-talkies, some at the funerals of the first day's dead. Dozens were killed, children among them, and thousands wounded, the injuries concentrated where a person holds and looks at a device: hands, faces, eyes. Beirut's surgeons operated through the night, many on patients who will not see again. Then the provenance unravelled in public. The pagers bore the brand of Gold Apollo of Taiwan, whose founder, Hsu Ching-kuang, said within a day that they were built under licence by BAC Consulting of Budapest. Hungary said BAC manufactured nothing on its soil. The New York Times, citing intelligence officers, reported that BAC was a front, erected as part of the operation itself. Icom of Osaka said the radio model in question went out of production a decade ago and that counterfeits are so common it could not verify the devices as its own. Every link in the chain, asked whether it was the link, pointed one link along.

The question this leaves for the rest of us seems simple and is not: once it is demonstrated that ordinary objects can be weaponised before delivery, at a link in the chain nobody can see, what follows? The first road is verification. Check the objects. For an individual this fails immediately; no one can open and understand the things they own, and a tampered device is built to pass the only inspections its owner can perform. Scale the idea up to states and it fails more interestingly, because the record shows the great verifiers moonlighting as the great tamperers. Among the documents Edward Snowden disclosed in 2014 were photographs of American intelligence officers intercepting Cisco routers in transit, fitting implants, resealing the factory cartons and sending them onward, so neatly that Cisco's chief executive wrote to the White House asking it to stop. Verification as a regime assumes a class of actors with the capability and no appetite for abuse, and the fortnight's lesson, stacked on 2014's, is that capability and appetite travel together.

The second road: shorten the chain. Make the critical objects at home, buy from allies, onshore the factories. This is the direction policy is already drifting for chips, and as industrial strategy it has real force, but as an answer here it dissolves twice over. Rich states might manage it for a few categories of device over decades; nobody else can, and Hezbollah's own story shows why the retreat is a trap rather than an exit: the group adopted pagers in the first place to escape the compromised smartphone, stepping deliberately down the technology ladder toward things simple enough to trust, and the step was anticipated and the simple thing was waiting for them. A defensive migration that an adversary can predict is not a defence; it is a funnel.

The third road is law. There exists treaty language on booby-traps, a protocol barring weapons built into apparently harmless portable objects, and Human Rights Watch invoked it within days, alongside the plainer point that no one triggering thousands of charges at once can know whether each device sits beside a fighter or a child at a kitchen table; the children are not hypothetical. But a rule does its work through the reception of its breach, and the reception, across much of the commentary, was applause for the tradecraft. Law whose violation is admired as ingenuity has a constituency problem that citing the text does not solve, and I do not know what solves it.

So all three roads close, and the honest move is to say so rather than dress the last of them as a destination. What remains is a fork I cannot see past. In Beirut this week people were pulling batteries out of devices and airlines were barring pagers from flights, which suggests a world where the demonstrated possibility keeps working on the mind long after the operation ends. And in the same city people were back to carrying phones within days, because there is no way to live otherwise, which suggests the trust we extend to objects is less a judgement that can be revised than a necessity that reasserts itself regardless of evidence. Whether a civilisation can learn what this fortnight taught about its objects and change anything at all, or will simply absorb the knowledge the way it absorbs everything, I genuinely cannot tell, and I am suspicious of anyone who, this soon, can.

The Back Page

The end of the long squeeze

It is easy to lose, amid the pagers and the debates and the wars, the quiet significance of what the Federal Reserve did this fortnight, so let us mark it plainly for the ordinary people it touches. For two and a half years, the price of money has been the highest in a generation, and it has pressed, silently and relentlessly, on almost everyone: the young couple who could not afford a mortgage, the small business whose loan payments doubled, the family whose credit-card balance became a trap, the would-be homeowner frozen out of a market where nobody could afford to buy and nobody with a cheap old loan would sell. The rate rises were the medicine for the inflation that had been eating everyone's wages, and the medicine worked, mostly, but it was bitter, and it fell hardest, as these things do, on those with the least cushion. On September 18, the Fed began, at last, to loosen the grip. It is not a return to the free money of the last decade, and it will not fix everything, and the relief will arrive slowly and unevenly. But for the first time in two and a half years, the direction reversed, and the long squeeze that has quietly shaped millions of lives, the deferred house, the abandoned plan, the tightened belt, began, gently, to ease. No one throws a party for a half-point rate cut. But in a hundred million households, the arithmetic of the possible just shifted, a little, toward the better, and that is worth a paragraph on the back page, because it is the kind of news that changes real lives while making no noise at all.

The Funnies
The new machine pauses to think before it speaks.
Trials in humans are ongoing.
The Oracle

The fortnight read across the heavens, Western and Eastern. Find your sign; the Oracle is never wrong, and never responsible.

The Western Stars
Aries21 Mar to 19 Apr

A beginning beckons. Begin it before a committee hears of it and improves it.

Taurus20 Apr to 20 May

A pleasure is earned this fortnight. Take it before the calendar notices.

Gemini21 May to 20 Jun

You will hold two opinions before noon and defend both with footnotes, depending entirely on the audience.

Cancer21 Jun to 22 Jul

A stranger's tone sets the weather for your whole day; forecast: drizzle, clearing only near the fridge.

Leo23 Jul to 22 Aug

Your exit from a room this week deserves, and will not receive, a standing ovation.

Virgo23 Aug to 22 Sep

Perfection beckons: you will redraft a two-line reply until it achieves the quiet gravity of scripture.

Libra23 Sep to 22 Oct

You will agree with the last person who spoke, then with the next, all in the name of harmony.

Scorpio23 Oct to 21 Nov

Your poker face is flawless; your browser history, mercifully, remains permanently classified.

Sagittarius22 Nov to 21 Dec

You will drop a hard truth at a soft moment and call it, generously, just keeping things real.

Capricorn22 Dec to 19 Jan

Rest is pencilled in for retirement, which you have, with characteristic foresight, brought forward and then postponed.

Aquarius20 Jan to 18 Feb

A radical idea arrives at 3am, fully formed and faintly illegal. Sleep on it.

Pisces19 Feb to 20 Mar

A dream recurs in which the deploy succeeds on the first try. Do not trust it.

The Chinese Zodiac
Rat1996 · 2008 · 2020

Someone throws out what you hoarded; you retrieve it at dusk, vindicated and faintly ashamed.

Ox1997 · 2009 · 2021

Great strength is wasted this week carrying a grudge the size of a wardrobe.

Tiger1998 · 2010 · 2022

Stalk the promotion quietly for once; the pounce is better when the numbers are watching.

Rabbit1999 · 2011 · 2023

Diplomacy triumphs; you say nothing memorable and are therefore invited back.

Dragon2000 · 2012 · 2024

You will make a grand entrance into a room that, regrettably, expected only the one guest.

Snake2001 · 2013 · 2025

Say nothing, know everything, and strike cleanly once; the second strike is simply vulgar.

Horse2002 · 2014 · 2026

A fence appears this fortnight, and with it the sudden certainty that the grass beyond is urgent.

Goat2003 · 2015 · 2027

A soft afternoon undoes your resolve, which was soft to begin with and now reclines completely.

Monkey1992 · 2004 · 2016

You will outsmart every obstacle except the mirror, which keeps outsmarting you straight back.

Rooster1993 · 2005 · 2017

Precision is yours, as is the urge to note, at volume, everyone else's regrettable lack of it.

Dog1994 · 2006 · 2018

You will guard a secret so faithfully that you forget you were the one it needed guarding from.

Pig1995 · 2007 · 2019

Comfort finds you early this week and declines, warmly, to let you up.

The Vedic Rashis
MeshaMangal · 14 Apr

A conflict ripens that is older than memory. The wheel returns it; meet it, do not inherit it again.

VrishabhaShukra · 15 May

A comfort you cling to was borrowed from a future you. Shukra's interest is patience, and it compounds.

MithunaBudh · 15 Jun

You will be right and unpersuasive, or wrong and believed. Budh asks which vanity you can afford to lose.

KarkaChandra · 17 Jul

Your heart asks for shelter the Moon cannot build. Make peace: some tides are meant to be felt, not fixed.

SimhaSurya · 17 Aug

Surya lights you generously, then notes who forgets the lamp is borrowed. Shine; the oil is not yours.

KanyaBudh · 17 Sep

Perfection is a horizon, not a destination. Mercury walks you toward it precisely so you never arrive.

TulaShukra · 18 Oct

A bond asks to be rebalanced, not abandoned. Shukra mends what pride would rather break.

VrishchikaMangal · 17 Nov

A buried thing surfaces. Transformation is not gentle; the serpent sheds the skin it loved. Let it go.

DhanuGuru · 16 Dec

Wisdom is fortune you cannot spend and cannot lose. Guru has been depositing it while you looked away.

MakaraShani · 15 Jan

Delay is not denial in Saturn's court. The wheel turns at its own weight; your impatience does not grease it.

KumbhaShani · 13 Feb

Shani stands you slightly apart from the crowd so you can see the shape it cannot see of itself. Report back kindly.

MeenaGuru · 15 Mar

Surrender is not defeat; it is Jupiter teaching the river to stop arguing with the sea it was always bound for.

Set after midnight, when the stories are quieter and tell the truth more readily.Set after hours by the Night Compositor