Here is the verdict, delivered up front: the tournament that opened across three countries this fortnight will lose its hosts money, the month will still be worth having, and the real scandal sits in neither half of that sentence but in a third place the argument only reaches at the end.
Take the first half under cross-examination. The costs are public: the stadiums, the security, the transport, the tens of billions the three treasuries have committed. The revenues are private to the governing body: broadcasting, sponsorship, ticketing, flowing to Zurich on contracts signed long before a ball was kicked. The compensations promised to hosts, tourism, development, legacy, have a documented habit of arriving smaller than projected, while the costs arrive larger, and this asymmetry has repeated across so many tournaments and so many decades that no serious auditor still treats it as open. Nothing in the opening fortnight disturbs the pattern. The first half of the verdict stands.
Now the second half, which the first half keeps trying to swallow. Set the accounts beside the month itself: billions watching, three countries full of strangers embracing over goals, the roar held in common in a year that has offered little to share but grief. Is that delight somehow fraudulent because the books behind it bleed? Stand on any street in any host city on a match night and the question embarrasses itself. A treasury cannot book joy, but households do not keep treasury books, and a public may sanely overpay for a festival; civilisations have always spent past reason on their feasts, and have been right to. So the second half of the verdict stands too, and the two halves sit in different currencies, and no exchange rate connects them, which is why the argument between them has run for decades without either side landing a blow the other feels.
Which exposes the third thing, the one the familiar quarrel is built to hide. If the delight is consumed by the public, and the bill is paid by the public, then in principle this could be an honourable transaction: a people choosing, eyes open, to buy itself a month of communal happiness at a known price. Except that no such choice was ever put. The bids were lodged years ago by federations and ministries; the projections placed before the publics were the flattering ones the record keeps refuting; the price was presented, where it was presented at all, as an investment that would repay itself, a claim its presenters had every historical reason to doubt. A purchase the buyer approves is a festival. The same purchase executed in the buyer's name, on figures the seller had seen fail before, is a different kind of event, and it would remain so even if, against all precedent, the books one day balanced.
So the opening sentence survives its trial, but it comes back narrower and aimed elsewhere. Losing money on a feast was never the offence; peoples are entitled to buy delight dear, and this month a weary one is doing so with evident relish, and good luck to it. The offence is the consent that was never requested and the prospectus that was never honest, and the remedy is not less football but a plainer question, put to hosts before the signing rather than after the spending: here is the real price, paid by you, and here is the real month, enjoyed by you, and do you want it? Some publics would say yes, and that yes would change what the spending is. Until the question is asked, the most beautiful month in sport will keep being bought for its hosts rather than by them, and the difference between those two small words is the whole of what the balance sheet has been trying, all these tournaments, to say.