Vol. II, No. 34
Covering 17 November - 30 November 2025
Monday, December 1, 2025
Late edition · A Relentless publication
All the fortnight that mattered, in technology and in the world, read next to what we were building at the time.
We do not break the news; we fold it, neatly, every other Monday.
UKRAINE

A "peace plan" written in Washington and Moscow, and handed to the victim to sign

A 28-point American plan to end the war leaked this fortnight, and it read, to Kyiv and its allies, less like a peace than a capitulation: Ukrainian territory ceded, its army capped, its NATO hopes ended, its future dictated by the two powers negotiating over its head. Europe scrambled to soften it. The victim was told to be grateful.

A plan to end the war in Ukraine, drafted by the American administration in close consultation with Moscow, emerged and landed in Kyiv like a blow. Its 28 points, as leaked, amounted to something close to Russia's maximum demands: Ukraine would cede territory it still holds, cap the size of its army, abandon its aspiration to join NATO, and accept a settlement negotiated substantially over its head between Washington and Moscow, with Europe and Ukraine itself relegated to accepting terms shaped by the two great powers. To Kyiv and its European allies, it read not as a peace but as a capitulation dressed as one, a reward to the aggressor for its aggression, and the imposition on the victim of terms it would never freely accept, under the threat that American support, already withdrawn once, would vanish entirely if it refused. Frantic diplomacy in Geneva produced a revised, somewhat softened version, and the negotiations churned on, but the message of the original draft was clear: the fate of Ukraine would be decided by the powerful, and the country whose blood had been spilled for four years would be handed the result to sign.

It was where the long reversal of the year finally came to rest, the transactional presidency's approach to the war reaching its logical end: peace defined not as justice or security for the invaded but as a deal between great powers, in which the aggressor is rewarded, the victim is pressured, and the outcome is measured by whether the fighting stops, not by whether the settlement is just or durable. Whether Ukraine could be forced to accept it, whether Europe could soften it enough to be survivable, whether Russia would honour any deal it signed, remained unresolved. But the spectacle of a plan to end a war of aggression that rewarded the aggressor and dictated terms to the victim was a fitting emblem of an order in which strength is honoured and principle is a luxury, and in which the difference between a peace and a capitulation is a distinction the powerful no longer trouble to make.

HONG KONG

A tower burns, and the scaffolding was the fuel

A catastrophic fire tore through a high-rise residential complex in Hong Kong on November 26, killing more than 150 people in one of the deadliest fires the city has ever seen. The blaze spread with terrifying speed up the exterior of the towers, and the reason was a familiar and preventable one: the buildings were wrapped in bamboo scaffolding and netting for renovation, and the highly flammable materials, along with foam sealing that failed to meet safety standards, turned the exteriors into a chimney that carried the fire up and across the complex faster than anyone could escape. Arrests followed, of the contractors responsible for the materials, and the questions were, wearily, the familiar ones: why the flammable materials, why the failed inspections, why the warnings about this very risk had not prevented this very catastrophe.

IN BRIEF

A shooting near the White House; the files forced out; a new model

A National Guard member was shot and killed near the White House on November 26 by an Afghan national who had entered the country years earlier, an attack the administration seized upon to intensify its already sweeping immigration crackdown and to suspend asylum processing. Congress forced the release of the Epstein investigative files after overwhelming bipartisan votes, a rare defeat for a president whose own supporters had demanded transparency. And Google released Gemini 3, its most capable AI model yet, widely judged to have leapt ahead of its rivals, a reminder that beneath the year's political chaos the technology's advance never paused.

The Column

Twenty-eight points, read slowly

The leaked plan for ending the war in Ukraine is, before anything else, a text. This column does one thing with it: a slow reading, clause by clause, cap and land and constitution and money and amnesty, letting the drafting speak for its drafters.

In the third week of November a 28-point plan to end the war in Ukraine, drafted by American officials in consultation with Moscow, leaked in full. Geneva has since produced a softened revision, nineteen points by most accounts, and the softening will continue. The original remains the text to read, because a first draft is where intention lives before the lawyers dress it for company, and what follows is nothing except a reading of it, one clause at a time.

Begin with the cap. One clause fixes the peacetime strength of Ukraine's armed forces at six hundred thousand. Read it twice. The number binds the army of the invaded country; no clause anywhere in the document binds the army that crossed the border. A reader handed this page knowing nothing of the war could reconstruct, from that asymmetry alone, which party sat nearest the pen.

Now the land. Crimea, Donetsk and Luhansk are to be recognised as de facto Russian, the United States among the recognisers, and the recognition covers ground in Donetsk that Ukraine holds today and would be required to vacate; the vacated ground becomes a demilitarised buffer, and the buffer itself is recognised as Russian. Kherson and Zaporizhzhia freeze along the line of contact. Follow the grammar through these clauses, because grammar is the one part of a draft nobody remembers to launder. Ukraine withdraws, Ukraine accepts, Ukraine recognises; Russia receives. Across the whole territorial section the invaded state is the subject of every verb of giving and the beneficiary of none.

The constitution next. Ukraine is to write into its founding law that it will never join NATO, and NATO in parallel is to record that it will never admit Ukraine. Hold the clause up to the light. A sovereign country's constitution, amended to the specification of the state that invaded it: the invader's central war aim, executed by the victim's own parliament and notarised by the alliance that declined to defend it. The clause does more than close a candidacy. It conscripts the victim into ratifying the stated reason for its own invasion.

Then the money, which repays the same slowness. One hundred billion dollars of Russia's frozen assets are to be invested in Ukraine's reconstruction under American leadership, with fifty per cent of the profits accruing to the United States. Europe adds a further hundred billion of its own. The remainder of the frozen Russian funds flows into a joint American-Russian investment vehicle. Trace each dollar's itinerary and the shape appears: the aggressor's impounded money rebuilds what the aggressor destroyed, under the management of the mediator, who keeps half the upside; the victim's allies pay in alongside; the aggressor finishes the war in a business partnership with the broker of its peace. The broker, in short, bills the fire, the firefighters and the house, and writes its own percentage into the settlement.

Two clauses on legitimacy belong side by side. Ukraine must hold elections within one hundred days. No electoral requirement of any kind attaches to Russia, which is instead to be welcomed back toward the G8 while sanctions come off in stages. In the document's scheme of obligations, voting is a duty laid on the democracy that was attacked, and normalisation is a gift extended to the autocracy that attacked it.

And then the clause I have reread more than all the others together, the amnesty: all parties are to receive full amnesty for their acts during the war. Set two facts from outside the text beside it. The International Criminal Court's warrant for Vladimir Putin concerns the unlawful deportation of Ukrainian children, of whom Kyiv's registry counts more than nineteen thousand. And the plan itself, in its humanitarian provisions, promises that the children will be returned, which means the drafters knew; the children are in the document. The same text that schedules their homecoming forgives, in advance and in full, the taking of them. A document discloses its loyalties in what it chooses to forgive, and this one forgives everything, for everyone, in a war that had one invader. Geneva may yet strike the clause. No account of the revisions, as I write, records that it has.

The Back Page

The scaffold and the sealant

More than 150 people died in Hong Kong this fortnight, and within days the coverage had settled on its villain: the bamboo, ancient and photogenic, the lattice of lashed poles that Hong Kong, almost alone among modern cities, still uses to dress its towers. The instinct is understandable. The bamboo burned, the bamboo is unusual, and an unusual thing that burned makes a satisfying cause. But the early findings point somewhere less photogenic, at the protective netting and the foam sealing boards that investigators say failed the required standards, modern synthetic materials, invisible in every skyline photograph, wrapped around the poles. Bamboo scaffolding has stood on this city's buildings for generations without producing a fire like this one; the non-compliant wrapping had to be added to it. Blame, though, does not flow toward causes. It flows toward whatever a camera can hold, and the likeliest casualty of the fortnight, after the dead, is a craft: the city had already begun easing bamboo off its public projects in the spring, and this fire will probably end the argument for good, retiring the material everyone could see on behalf of the materials nobody could. The inquiry will report in a year or so, in paragraphs no one will film, and whatever it finds about the foam and the netting will matter less, by then, than the silhouette of burning poles already has.