Just after eleven on the night of June 2, 1919, a bomb took the front off 2132 R Street in Washington, the home of A. Mitchell Palmer, Attorney General of the United States. The man who carried it, an Italian anarchist named Carlo Valdinoci, died on the steps when the charge went off early; fragments of him were found far down the block and on the doorstep opposite, where Franklin Roosevelt, then the young assistant secretary of the navy, had come home minutes before with his wife. Bombs detonated that same night outside officials' homes in seven other cities, and around every site fluttered a printed leaflet titled Plain Words, signed by the Anarchist Fighters. The terror was real, coordinated and aimed at named men, and the fear of that American summer had a crater to point to.
Palmer, a Quaker progressive who had once declined the war ministry on grounds of conscience, answered the crater with an apparatus. Inside the Justice Department he created a General Intelligence Division and handed it to a 24-year-old clerk named J. Edgar Hoover, who built a card index of radicals that soon held two hundred thousand names, filed not by acts committed but by memberships held, meetings attended, newspapers subscribed to. On November 7, 1919, agents raided the Union of Russian Workers across a dozen cities, and men were beaten down the staircases of the Russian People's House on East 15th Street in New York. On December 21 the army transport Buford steamed out of New York harbour with 249 deportees aboard, Emma Goldman and Alexander Berkman the famous names among them, most of the rest guilty of belonging to an organisation and of nothing further.
The great sweep came on the night of January 2, 1920, in more than thirty cities at once. Thousands of men were seized in that single night, out of meeting halls, pool rooms and kitchens, most without warrants, held without charge, questioned without lawyers. In Detroit, roughly eight hundred were penned for days in a windowless corridor of the federal building with a single drinking fountain. Citizens were swept in alongside aliens, and membership rolls were read as confessions to crimes not yet committed. Palmer then informed the newspapers that the revolution itself had a date: it would begin on May 1, 1920. Police forces across the country mobilised and sat waiting. May Day came and went without an incident anywhere in America.
What ended it was a 71-year-old official with a pen. Deportation orders required a counter-signature at the Labor Department, and the man holding that pen in the spring of 1920 was Louis F. Post, the assistant secretary, who insisted on reading every case file as though the person inside it had rights, which, he kept pointing out, the statutes said they did. Where a file showed no act, he cancelled the warrant, by the hundred and then by the thousand, until of the vast January haul just 556 people were ultimately deported. Congress moved to impeach him for it. In May the old man sat before the House Rules Committee and read aloud from the files themselves, name after name, what each accused person had been shown to have done, which was, in file after file, nothing; the impeachment effort did not survive the reading. The same month, twelve lawyers of national standing, Felix Frankfurter and Roscoe Pound among them, published a documented report on the department's illegal arrests and detentions, affidavits and photographs attached. Palmer went to his party's convention that June expecting the raids to have made him president. They had made him an embarrassment instead, and the episode that carries his name became the kind of history a country tells against itself as warning.
Two artefacts outlived the panic. That same January, in the middle of the raids, a small group of lawyers and dissenters organised what became the American Civil Liberties Union, built for the specific purpose of standing between the apparatus and its lists. And Hoover kept the index. He would run American domestic intelligence for another half-century, and the filing system born of the crater on R Street never afterwards lacked for names.
Charlie Kirk was murdered in Utah on September 10, in front of a crowd, and the grief around his killing is as real as the crater was. Within days the government was naming the networks, the funders, the whole political tendency that would be made to answer for one man's bullet, and by the 17th a broadcaster had pulled Jimmy Kimmel off the air over a monologue. The year 1920 does not say the fear is false; the fear had dynamite behind it then too. It says the fear will be handed lists, that the lists will fill with people who did nothing, and that how far it all goes depends on who, this time, is holding Louis Post's pen.