Gunmen kill 26 people at Pahalgam, almost all of them tourists, and India and Pakistan move toward confrontation
Gunmen killed 26 people, almost all tourists, at a beauty spot in Kashmir. India blamed Pakistan, suspended the treaty that shares their rivers, and moved troops to the border. Two nuclear-armed neighbours moved, once more, toward open conflict.
Gunmen opened fire on tourists at Pahalgam, a scenic meadow in Indian-administered Kashmir, on April 22, killing 26 people, almost all of them Indian visitors, in the deadliest attack on civilians in the region in years, singling out victims, survivors said, by religion. India blamed Pakistan-based militants and, beyond them, the Pakistani state, and responded in terms that went well past the usual exchange of condemnations: it suspended the Indus Waters Treaty, the 1960 agreement that governs the rivers on which Pakistan's agriculture depends and that had survived every previous war between the two countries, expelled diplomats, closed the border, and moved forces forward. Pakistan denied involvement, called the treaty suspension an act of war, and readied its own forces. Two nuclear-armed nations, with four wars behind them and an unresolved claim on Kashmir between them, were closer to open conflict than at any point in years, while much of the world's attention was on tariffs and a papal funeral.
The suspension of the water treaty marked something new and dangerous. For 65 years, through wars hot and cold, the Indus Waters Treaty had held, the one sustained area of cooperation between the two states, because both sides had treated water as too fundamental to use as leverage. India's suspension of it, in response to the killings, crossed a line that had held for two generations, threatening the water supply of a nation of 240 million and signalling that this crisis would be fought without the old restraints. Whether it escalated to open war or was pulled back from the brink depended on decisions being made in Delhi and Islamabad under the pressure of public anger and the logic of deterrence, between two states that hold, between them, some 300 nuclear weapons.