Vol. I, No. 19
Covering 21 April - 4 May 2025
Monday, May 5, 2025
Late edition · A Relentless publication
All the fortnight that mattered, in technology and in the world, read next to what we were building at the time.
Everything here happened; the arrangement is ours.
KASHMIR

Gunmen kill 26 people at Pahalgam, almost all of them tourists, and India and Pakistan move toward confrontation

Gunmen killed 26 people, almost all tourists, at a beauty spot in Kashmir. India blamed Pakistan, suspended the treaty that shares their rivers, and moved troops to the border. Two nuclear-armed neighbours moved, once more, toward open conflict.

Gunmen opened fire on tourists at Pahalgam, a scenic meadow in Indian-administered Kashmir, on April 22, killing 26 people, almost all of them Indian visitors, in the deadliest attack on civilians in the region in years, singling out victims, survivors said, by religion. India blamed Pakistan-based militants and, beyond them, the Pakistani state, and responded in terms that went well past the usual exchange of condemnations: it suspended the Indus Waters Treaty, the 1960 agreement that governs the rivers on which Pakistan's agriculture depends and that had survived every previous war between the two countries, expelled diplomats, closed the border, and moved forces forward. Pakistan denied involvement, called the treaty suspension an act of war, and readied its own forces. Two nuclear-armed nations, with four wars behind them and an unresolved claim on Kashmir between them, were closer to open conflict than at any point in years, while much of the world's attention was on tariffs and a papal funeral.

The suspension of the water treaty marked something new and dangerous. For 65 years, through wars hot and cold, the Indus Waters Treaty had held, the one sustained area of cooperation between the two states, because both sides had treated water as too fundamental to use as leverage. India's suspension of it, in response to the killings, crossed a line that had held for two generations, threatening the water supply of a nation of 240 million and signalling that this crisis would be fought without the old restraints. Whether it escalated to open war or was pulled back from the brink depended on decisions being made in Delhi and Islamabad under the pressure of public anger and the logic of deterrence, between two states that hold, between them, some 300 nuclear weapons.

THE WORLD

Voters abroad punish anything that looks like Trump

An unexpected pattern emerged from elections across the democratic world: association with Donald Trump had become electoral poison. In Canada, the Liberal Party, written off for dead months ago, surged to victory on April 28 under Mark Carney, its revival powered almost entirely by a nationalist backlash against Trump's tariffs and his musings about annexing the country. Days later, on May 3, Australia's Labor government under Anthony Albanese won a thumping re-election, as its conservative opposition, tarred by comparisons to the American president, collapsed. The global anti-incumbent wave of 2024 had reversed: in 2025, incumbents who could position themselves against Trump were thriving, and the opposition parties that had borrowed his style were being punished.

IN BRIEF

A conclave gathers; a president's hundred days; an oracle steps back

The cardinals of the Catholic Church gathered in Rome to bury Pope Francis on April 26, a funeral that drew world leaders including a brief, awkward encounter between Trump and Zelensky, and then to begin the conclave that would choose his successor. Trump marked 100 days in office on April 29 with the lowest approval ratings of any president at that milestone in the modern era, as data showed the American economy had shrunk in the first quarter. And Warren Buffett, at 94, announced that he would step down at year's end as chief executive of Berkshire Hathaway, ending the most storied run in the history of investing.

The Column

The man who was rich by waiting

Warren Buffett stepped down after sixty years, and the tributes reached for the wrong word. He was not a genius of the markets. He was something rarer and plainer, and the difference is the whole of what he has to teach.

Warren Buffett announced this fortnight that he would hand over Berkshire Hathaway at the year's end, closing a run of about sixty years that turned a failing textile mill into one of the largest companies on earth and made him, along the way, the most studied investor who ever lived. The tributes have mostly reached for the word genius, and it is the wrong word, or at least it points in the wrong direction, because it suggests a man who saw what others could not, some flashing quantitative gift, a mind moving faster than the market. He was not that. What he had was rarer and far less exciting, and the gap between what he actually did and what the word genius implies is the most useful thing about him.

What Buffett had was temperament, and temperament is the one edge that cannot be bought, taught, or automated. His actual method was almost insultingly simple and has been public for decades: buy good businesses at fair prices, hold them more or less forever, ignore the noise, and let compounding do the work that no cleverness can rival. There is no secret in it; he published the whole recipe every year in a folksy letter anyone could read. The reason almost no one replicates it is not that the method is hard to understand but that it is nearly impossible to execute, because executing it means doing nothing for years at a stretch while everyone around you is doing something and getting rich at it, means sitting on cash through a bubble while your rivals crow, means buying when the world is ending and refusing to buy when the world is euphoric, means, above all, being patient in a profession that pays people to be busy. The method is arithmetic. The temperament is the entire game, and temperament is what the market selects against, rewarding the frantic and the fashionable right up until it doesn't.

That is why his most quoted line, that you should be fearful when others are greedy and greedy when others are fearful, is easy to recite and almost impossible to obey. It asks you to feel the opposite of what every person around you is feeling, at the precise moment the feeling is strongest, which is a demand not on the intellect but on the nerves, and nerves are not distributed to the clever. The dot-com mania, the crypto manias, the meme-stock spasms, the whole recurring carnival of the sure thing that everyone is getting rich on except you: Buffett sat out every one of them, endured the mockery each time for being a dinosaur who did not understand the new era, and was proved right each time not because he predicted the crash but because he simply declined to play a game whose rules he could not see. He was rich, in the end, by waiting, and waiting is the one strategy that no amount of processing power or financial engineering has ever managed to improve upon.

The timing of his exit carries its own lesson, too, arriving as it does in an age loud with the opposite of everything he was. He leaves in a market drunk on artificial intelligence, on the promise of returns too large and too soon to be quite believed, on the conviction, eternal and eternally renewed, that this time the old rules of value and patience have been repealed by something new. They have not. They never are. Buffett's whole career was a sixty-year demonstration that the fundamentals do not change, that a business is worth what it will earn and not a penny of the story told about it, and that the people who forget this in the excitement of each new era are the reliable, recurring donors to the patience of the people who do not.

So the man steps down, and the eulogies call him a wizard, and he would be the first to wave the word away. He was not a wizard. He was a supremely disciplined ordinary man who understood one unfashionable truth deeply enough to hold it through sixty years of temptation to abandon it, and who got, as his reward, the slow and unspectacular miracle of compounding left alone to work. The lesson he leaves is not a stock tip or a secret. It is that the hardest thing in any market, and maybe in any life, is to do nothing when doing nothing is right, and that the returns on that terrible discipline, latent for years and then enormous, are the closest thing to magic that patience has ever produced.

Field Notes
A Relentless build, told plainly

The system that was perfect and still failed

I have built systems that were excellent by every technical measure and failed completely, because no one used them. A brilliant tool people route around is worth less than a modest one they rely on. No client is named.

I have built systems that were, by every technical measure, excellent, and that failed completely, because no one used them. It is the most common and most demoralising failure in enterprise software, and it taught me the single most important lesson of my career: that a system is only ever worth what people actually do with it, and that getting human beings to adopt it, to change how they work, to trust it, to use it the way it was designed to be used, is the work that decides whether all the building amounted to anything at all. A brilliant system that people route around, that they quietly keep doing the old way beside, that they enter bad data into because they never understood why it mattered, is worth less than a mediocre system that people genuinely use, because software delivers its value only when it is actually used, and use is a human problem, not a technical one.

The mistake I made early, and watch others make constantly, is to treat adoption as an afterthought, something you handle with a training session at the end, once the real work of building is done. It is backwards. The people who will have to use the system are not obstacles to be managed after the fact; they are the entire point, and if you have not understood their actual work, their real incentives, the reasons they do things the way they currently do, then you have not gathered requirements, you have gathered wishes, and the system you build will collide with reality the day it ships. People do not resist new systems because they are stupid or stubborn. They resist because the new system asks them to change, and change is costly to them personally, and if the system does not visibly make their own working life better, they will, entirely rationally, keep doing what they know, whatever the org chart says. Adoption is not won by mandate. It is won by building something that actually serves the people who have to use it, and by bringing them along from the start so that it is, in a real sense, theirs.

This is why I have come to believe that the human side of building software, the change management, the training, the patient work of understanding and winning over the people who will use the thing, is not soft, secondary, or separable from the engineering. It is the engineering, the part that determines whether the technical work delivers any value at all. And it connects, strangely, to this fortnight's darker front page: the deepest truth of both is that systems, technical or social, only work when the people inside them actually honour them, use them, hold them. You can build the finest system in the world, or agree the finest treaty, and if the humans do not adopt it, do not use it, do not hold to it when it costs them something, it is worth nothing. And you win people not by mandate but by building something that genuinely earns its place in their working day and bringing them along from the first conversation, until the system is, in a real sense, theirs; which is why a modest tool people own and lean on will always be worth more than a brilliant one they have quietly learned to route around.

The Back Page

The grown-up in the room

Mark Carney has spent his career being the person called in when things break: a central banker in Canada through the 2008 crash, then the first non-Briton to run the Bank of England, through the long mess of Brexit, the technocrat's technocrat, unelected and unflashy and trusted because he was neither. Canadians, rattled by a neighbour suddenly talking of tariffs and annexation, did something that a year ago looked impossible: they handed the top elected job to that man, a banker who had never held a seat in Parliament, on the strength of a single proposition, that in a dangerous moment you want the steady hand and not the loud one. It runs against the current of the age. Everywhere else the mood has rewarded the performer, the disruptor, the one who promises to break the thing; Canada, frightened, reached instead for the man whose entire brand is that he will not do anything stupid, who reads the balance sheet before he reads the room. We have a soft spot for that choice, on the old conviction that competence looks unremarkable right up until the afternoon it is the only thing standing between a country and the cliff. Carney may yet disappoint, for governing is not central banking, and the electorate that hires the grown-up tends to tire of him the moment the emergency passes. But for one fortnight a country looked at a frightening world and chose, deliberately, the least exciting person in it, and there is something quietly heartening in a democracy that, under real pressure, still knows the difference between a showman and a safe pair of hands.

A Dispatch Tale

The Shop of Small Repairs

A shop that mended kettles and clocks, until people began bringing other things.

A shop opened one spring on a street too quiet to notice, with a hand-painted sign in the window that said only SMALL REPAIRS, and for a while the people who went in went in with the ordinary broken things: a kettle that would not switch off, a clock three minutes slow, a chair with a wobble. The old man behind the counter fixed them without fuss and charged very little, and word got round that he was good, and the little bell over his door rang more and more often.

Then, because word had got round, people began to bring him other things. A man came in one Tuesday and set nothing at all on the counter and said, after a while, that it was the Tuesday itself he wanted mended, that it had gone wrong in a way he could not undo, and could the old man do anything. A woman brought a conversation she wished she had never had, carrying it the way you carry something fragile and too heavy at once. A boy of about sixteen brought a friendship with a crack running through it and would not meet the old man's eye.

The old man looked at each of them a long time, the way he looked at a clock before he opened it, and to most of them he said the same thing, gently: that he could not mend it, that no one could, that the most he could do was clean it up a little and hand it back, and that the mending, if there was going to be any, had always been theirs to do and never his. He showed the man with the Tuesday how to set it down. He told the woman that the conversation could not be unsaid but could, in time, be answered. He said nothing clever at all to the boy, only that cracks and breaks were different things, and that a crack, left alone and not leaned on too hard, sometimes held.

And they left, each of them, a little disappointed and a little lighter, which the old man had learned across a long life was the most an honest repair shop could ever promise, and very nearly enough.

The Oracle

The fortnight read across the heavens, Western and Eastern. Find your sign; the Oracle is never wrong, and never responsible.

The Western Stars
Aries21 Mar to 19 Apr

You will start four projects before breakfast and finish none, a personal best you will nonetheless announce to strangers.

Taurus20 Apr to 20 May

A new habit beckons for nine days before you return, unrepentant, to the old one that came with snacks.

Gemini21 May to 20 Jun

The group chat crowns you narrator; you narrate events you were, strictly speaking, not actually present for.

Cancer21 Jun to 22 Jul

You will weep at an advert for insurance and insist, firmly, that it was the lighting.

Leo23 Jul to 22 Aug

You will dress devastatingly for the occasion, the occasion being collecting a parcel from the hallway.

Virgo23 Aug to 22 Sep

You will correct someone's grammar mid-crisis and wonder, with genuine confusion, why the crisis deepens.

Libra23 Sep to 22 Oct

Offered the final slice, you will offer it onward until it congeals, a small monument to good manners.

Scorpio23 Oct to 21 Nov

You will keep a secret beautifully, then post it, as the stars always knew you would.

Sagittarius22 Nov to 21 Dec

The horizon widens. So does the scope. Neither was approved.

Capricorn22 Dec to 19 Jan

Ambition is rewarded with more ambition, plus a recurring calendar invite.

Aquarius20 Jan to 18 Feb

Your best idea is twenty years early and, briefly, illegal.

Pisces19 Feb to 20 Mar

A feeling is trying to tell you something. It is: lunch.

The Chinese Zodiac
Rat1996 · 2008 · 2020

A rumour of scarcity sends you buying tinned goods you will neither eat nor forgive yourself for.

Ox1997 · 2009 · 2021

You will not be moved this week, which is awkward, as the field needs ploughing and you are standing in it.

Tiger1998 · 2010 · 2022

Caution whispers something sensible; you do not speak that language, and leap regardless.

Rabbit1999 · 2011 · 2023

Diplomacy carries the day, largely by your not being in the room when the shouting begins.

Dragon2000 · 2012 · 2024

You will breathe fire upon a small inconvenience and set the larger agenda alight as well.

Snake2001 · 2013 · 2025

You will slip from a tightening situation and reappear, sleeker, in considerably warmer sun.

Horse2002 · 2014 · 2026

You will run magnificently in a wide circle and pronounce it, truthfully, excellent exercise.

Goat2003 · 2015 · 2027

You will be led gently toward a decision by anyone who speaks last and smiles.

Monkey1992 · 2004 · 2016

A shortcut you invent works perfectly once, then becomes legend, then becomes everyone's problem.

Rooster1993 · 2005 · 2017

Meticulous preparation ensures that when things go wrong they go wrong in alphabetical order.

Dog1994 · 2006 · 2018

Duty calls, as it always does, at the precise moment you had finally sat down.

Pig1995 · 2007 · 2019

You give away the better half and find yourself, somehow, with the better half.

The Vedic Rashis
MeshaMangal · 14 Apr

The red planet rewards the brave and buries the reckless in the same soil. Choose which you are by Thursday.

VrishabhaShukra · 15 May

Shukra lays a soft table, then watches who mistakes comfort for arrival. The senses are a road, not a home.

MithunaBudh · 15 Jun

Two truths will contradict you this fortnight, and both will be yours. Mercury smiles; he arranged it.

KarkaChandra · 17 Jul

You feel everything twice this fortnight: once as it happens, once as memory. Chandra charges no less.

SimhaSurya · 17 Aug

A throne offered this fortnight comes with its own weather. The Sun warms the crown and the headache equally.

KanyaBudh · 17 Sep

Your body speaks in the margins you skim. The graha of detail asks only that you read the fine print.

TulaShukra · 18 Oct

You seek fairness in a tilted world. Shukra admires the effort and gently recommends choosing your battles.

VrishchikaMangal · 17 Nov

Mangal rules your deep water, where things do not die so much as wait. Something down there is stirring awake.

DhanuGuru · 16 Dec

Fortune smiles on you this cycle, which the wise know is simply karma repaying an old, forgotten kindness.

MakaraShani · 15 Jan

The reward comes, Saturn promises, exactly when you have stopped needing it to arrive. That is the lesson, not the cruelty.

KumbhaShani · 13 Feb

You carry a vision the many are not ready for. Saturn counsels patience: the future keeps office hours no one controls.

MeenaGuru · 15 Mar

Fortune comes to you sideways, through faith you cannot defend in daylight. Trust it anyway; the planet has its reasons.

Small Ads

Notices, personals, and things lost or for sale, from in and around the works.

FOR SALE: roadmap, mostly fiction, suitable for framing.

FOR SALE: open-plan office, two hundred desks, six in use. Echoes included.

FOR SALE: one digital transformation, half-finished, would suit a buyer with more nerve than the last one.

FOR SALE: one unused gym membership and the optimism that came with it.

WANTED: senior engineer, fifteen years' experience in a framework released two years ago.

WANTED: the person who approved this. No questions, mostly.

A petal was hidden somewhere this evening. The Compositor has, honestly, forgotten where.Set after hours by the Night Compositor