The president deports men to a foreign prison, a judge says stop, and the administration does not stop
Invoking a wartime law from 1798, the government flew planeloads of Venezuelans to a maximum-security prison in El Salvador. A federal judge ordered the flights turned around. They landed anyway. The question is no longer what the president will do, but whether the courts can still make him stop.
The gravest constitutional confrontation of the new presidency arrived this fortnight, and it arrived over airplanes. Invoking the Alien Enemies Act of 1798, a wartime law used only three times in the nation's history, the administration declared a Venezuelan gang an invading force and, on that basis, flew planeloads of Venezuelan men, many with no criminal record and no hearing, to CECOT, the notorious mega-prison in El Salvador, to be held indefinitely at America's request. A federal judge, learning of the flights while they were in the air, ordered them turned around. They did not turn around; they landed, the men were marched into the Salvadoran prison, and the administration offered a series of evasions, that the order came too late, that it did not apply over international waters, that the judge had no authority, amounting to a single, stark reality: a court had said stop, and the executive had not stopped.
This is the confrontation that the checks-and-balances system exists to prevent and is least equipped to survive: an executive that simply declines to obey the judiciary. The courts have no army; their power rests entirely on the expectation that their orders will be followed, an expectation built over two centuries and now being tested as never before. If the administration can deport men to a foreign dungeon in defiance of a judge's order and face no consequence, then the judicial check, the layer above the executive that can say no, has been revealed as advisory, and the structure that restrains presidential power has a hole in it the size of a runway. The men in CECOT, disappeared into a foreign prison without a hearing, are the immediate victims. The principle at stake, whether any court can still make this president stop, is the one that will determine what the next four years become.