Vol. I, No. 16
Covering 10 March - 23 March 2025
Monday, March 24, 2025
Late edition · A Relentless publication
All the fortnight that mattered, in technology and in the world, read next to what we were building at the time.
Slow news, taken seriously.
WASHINGTON

The president deports men to a foreign prison, a judge says stop, and the administration does not stop

Invoking a wartime law from 1798, the government flew planeloads of Venezuelans to a maximum-security prison in El Salvador. A federal judge ordered the flights turned around. They landed anyway. The question is no longer what the president will do, but whether the courts can still make him stop.

The gravest constitutional confrontation of the new presidency arrived this fortnight, and it arrived over airplanes. Invoking the Alien Enemies Act of 1798, a wartime law used only three times in the nation's history, the administration declared a Venezuelan gang an invading force and, on that basis, flew planeloads of Venezuelan men, many with no criminal record and no hearing, to CECOT, the notorious mega-prison in El Salvador, to be held indefinitely at America's request. A federal judge, learning of the flights while they were in the air, ordered them turned around. They did not turn around; they landed, the men were marched into the Salvadoran prison, and the administration offered a series of evasions, that the order came too late, that it did not apply over international waters, that the judge had no authority, amounting to a single, stark reality: a court had said stop, and the executive had not stopped.

This is the confrontation that the checks-and-balances system exists to prevent and is least equipped to survive: an executive that simply declines to obey the judiciary. The courts have no army; their power rests entirely on the expectation that their orders will be followed, an expectation built over two centuries and now being tested as never before. If the administration can deport men to a foreign dungeon in defiance of a judge's order and face no consequence, then the judicial check, the layer above the executive that can say no, has been revealed as advisory, and the structure that restrains presidential power has a hole in it the size of a runway. The men in CECOT, disappeared into a foreign prison without a hearing, are the immediate victims. The principle at stake, whether any court can still make this president stop, is the one that will determine what the next four years become.

DIPLOMACY

America and Russia talk over Ukraine's head, and a fragile partial truce emerges

The remaking of the Ukraine war continued as Washington and Moscow negotiated its terms largely between themselves. A call between Trump and Putin on March 18 produced a limited agreement to pause attacks on energy infrastructure, a partial and fragile step that fell far short of the full ceasefire Trump had promised, and that was negotiated in a framework where Ukraine and Europe remained more spectators than participants in decisions about their own security. Kyiv, cut off from American intelligence and weapons weeks earlier and desperate to restore the relationship, accepted what it was offered while Europe scrambled to build the capacity to support Ukraine without the American backing it could no longer assume.

IN BRIEF

A strike on Yemen; a jailed rival; a long-delayed homecoming

American forces launched a sustained bombing campaign against the Houthis in Yemen from March 15, in response to the group's continued attacks on Red Sea shipping. In Turkey, President Erdogan had his most formidable political rival, the Istanbul mayor Ekrem Imamoglu, arrested on corruption charges widely seen as a pretext to eliminate a challenger, triggering the largest protests in a decade. And two NASA astronauts, Butch Wilmore and Suni Williams, finally returned to Earth on March 18 after more than nine months stranded aboard the International Space Station, a mission meant to last eight days extended into an odyssey by the failure of the Boeing spacecraft that had carried them up.

The Column

The manifest

Three aeroplanes, two hundred and sixty-one men, a statute from 1798, six million dollars, and the tattoos by which their families recognised them. The fortnight set down item by item, from the filings and the footage.

The law first. The Alien Enemies Act was passed in 1798, under John Adams, for a feared war with revolutionary France. It permits the detention and removal of nationals of a hostile power without hearings, upon a declared war or an "invasion or predatory incursion". It has been used three times in two and a quarter centuries: in the War of 1812, in the First World War, and in the Second, when it helped fill the internment camps with Japanese, German and Italian nationals. On the fourteenth of March the president signed a proclamation declaring a Venezuelan gang, Tren de Aragua, to be perpetrating an invasion of the United States. The fourth use had begun before the public knew the paper existed.

The fifteenth of March, a Saturday. The proclamation is published in the morning. Lawyers who had anticipated it are before a federal judge in Washington by the afternoon. During a recess in the hearing, two charter aircraft lift off from Harlingen, Texas, carrying shackled men. Toward seven in the evening the judge, James Boasberg, rules that no one may be removed under the proclamation, and says from the bench that any plane already flying is to come back, "however that's accomplished". His written order enters the docket at 7:26pm. At 7:37 a third aircraft takes off. None of the three turns.

Sunday morning the president of El Salvador posts a produced film: lines of men bent double between guards, heads shaved on arrival, run into the Terrorism Confinement Centre at Tecoluca, a prison built for forty thousand, where there are no visits, no programmes and no sentence to finish, the men on the metal tiers not having been convicted of anything. "Oopsie... Too late," he writes above a headline about the judge's order, and the American secretary of state reposts it. For a year of this custody the United States is paying El Salvador about six million dollars, covering 238 Venezuelans and 23 Salvadorans.

Where families have forced the government's evidence into the open, it is on the men's skin. Jerce Reyes Barrios, thirty-six, a professional goalkeeper from Machiques, has a crown tattooed above a football with a rosary and the word "Dios"; his lawyer's declaration says he chose it in honour of Real Madrid, and that the file against him consisted of the tattoo and a photograph of his hand making a rock-and-roll sign. Andry Hernandez Romero, a thirty-one-year-old makeup artist from Capacho who fled threats over being gay and passed his credible-fear interview, has a crown on each wrist; on the thirteenth of March he was due before an immigration judge in San Diego, and the government could not produce him, because he had been moved to Texas for the flights. Mervin Yamarte, twenty-nine, who left Maracaibo for Dallas and a job in a tortilla factory, was recognised by his mother in the Salvadoran footage. An immigration official's sworn declaration, filed in the operation's defence, states that many of the men have no criminal record in the United States, and argues that the absence of information about them "highlights the risk they pose".

In the courtroom since: the government has declined to tell the judge when the planes took off, when they left American airspace, or when custody changed hands, on the ground that the answers touch national security. It has argued that an order spoken from the bench binds less than a written one, and that the written one came too late to matter over international waters. The judge has called its answers woefully insufficient. The men have been charged with no crime in either country, and their relatives do what can be done from Venezuela, which is to study the film frame by frame for a known walk, a known profile, a known marking.

In Capacho, the town Andry Hernandez Romero comes from, the festival of the Three Kings has been staged every January for more than a century, and he had performed in it since he was seven years old. The crowns on his wrists are the kings' crowns. Beside one is the word "Mom". Beside the other, "Dad".

The Back Page

Home, after nine months

They went up for eight days and came home after nine months. Butch Wilmore and Suni Williams, two veteran NASA astronauts, launched last summer on the first crewed test of Boeing's new Starliner spacecraft, a mission planned to last a little over a week. Then the Starliner developed thruster problems and helium leaks, and NASA judged it too risky to bring them home in, and sent it back empty, and the two astronauts, who had packed for eight days, found themselves residents of the International Space Station for the better part of a year, waiting for a ride. They took it with the unflappable good humour that is the astronaut's stock in trade, folded themselves into the station's routines, did the science, waited. And this fortnight, at last, a SpaceX capsule brought them down, splashing into the Gulf off Florida after 286 days in orbit, carried out of the capsule on stretchers as their bodies readjusted to a gravity they had not felt since last spring. It became, inevitably, a political football, whose fault, who to blame, and there is a real story there about Boeing's troubles and a space programme's dependencies. But strip that away and it is, at heart, a small human epic: two people who went up for a week, got stranded by a machine that failed, and spent nine months in the great silence above the world, doing their jobs, trusting that a way home would come, and it did. They are back. The eight-day mission took nine months. They never once, in public, complained.

Corrections & Amplifications
A Dispatch Tale

The Low Shelf Behind the Desk

When the order came to remove certain books, a mild woman followed it exactly.

When the order came down that certain books were to be removed from the town library, the librarian, a mild woman whom no one had ever known to raise her voice, did a mild and quiet thing. She took the books off the open shelves, exactly as instructed, and she did not burn them or hide them or make a speech. She put them on a low shelf behind her own desk, where she could reach them without rising, and she wrote in her small catalogue, in the same hand she used for everything, that these titles were available on request.

No one had told her she could not do that, because no one had imagined she would. The order had assumed, as such orders do, that removing a thing from view was the same as removing it, and that a mild woman who followed instructions to the letter would follow them in spirit too. She followed them to the letter and not one inch further, and the letter, as it turned out, left her a great deal of room.

The requests were few at first, and shy. A teacher. A girl of sixteen who had heard the books were dangerous and wished to find out why. An old man who had read one of them in his youth and wanted to see whether it was as he remembered. The librarian fetched each book from behind her desk without comment, stamped it, and watched it go out into the town and come back, and stamped it in again, and said nothing to anyone.

Years later, when the order was quietly rescinded, as such orders quietly are, the books went back on the open shelves and the low shelf behind the desk stood empty, and almost no one ever knew it had been full. But the librarian knew, and the teacher knew, and the girl, by then a woman, knew. A right is not usually lost in a single great seizure. It is lost in a thousand small surrenders by people who were only following instructions, and it is kept, when it is kept, by people who follow the instructions exactly and not one inch further, and who understand that the space the letter leaves is the space where the thing itself survives.

Small Ads

Notices, personals, and things lost or for sale, from in and around the works.

LOST: faith in the quarterly forecast. Last seen rounding itself up.

NOTICE: the migration is complete. We have migrated to a new and identical set of problems.

PERSONALS: tired sysadmin seeks anyone, anyone at all, who has tried turning it off and on again.

WANTED: a geopolitical risk that was actually on the risk register. Finder keeps the register.

FOR SALE: minimum viable product, now maximally viable, no longer a product. Offers.

FOUND: the single source of truth. There were four. We regret the arithmetic.

Everything in its measure, the way the old hands taught, who are mostly gone now.Set after hours by the Night Compositor