Vol. I, No. 14
Covering 10 February - 23 February 2025
Monday, February 24, 2025
Late edition · A Relentless publication
All the fortnight that mattered, in technology and in the world, read next to what we were building at the time.
Two weeks of the world, read at the speed of paper.
THE ALLIANCE

America turns on Ukraine and courts Russia, and 80 years of the Western order crack in a fortnight

The new administration opened talks with Moscow that excluded Ukraine and Europe, blamed Kyiv for the war, and called Zelensky a dictator. At Munich, the vice-president told Europe its real enemy was within. The transatlantic alliance, the bedrock of the postwar world, is breaking.

The foundation of the Western world shifted this fortnight with a speed that left Europe reeling. The Trump administration opened direct negotiations with Russia over the war in Ukraine, in talks held in Saudi Arabia on February 18 from which Ukraine itself, and Europe, were pointedly excluded, signalling that the fate of the continent would be decided over the heads of the people whose continent it is. President Trump went further, echoing Kremlin talking points by suggesting Ukraine had started the war, and calling President Zelensky "a dictator without elections," an extraordinary inversion that cast the invaded democracy as the villain and the invading autocrat as the partner. And at the Munich Security Conference on February 14, Vice-President Vance stunned an audience of Europe's leaders by lecturing them not on the Russian threat but on their own alleged failures of democracy and free speech, telling them, in effect, that the enemy they should fear was within their own societies.

Europe understood that something 80 years old had broken. Since 1945 the security of Western Europe had rested on a single foundation: the American guarantee, the promise that the United States would defend its allies, that the transatlantic alliance was permanent, that Europe could shelter under the American umbrella and need not fully provide for its own defence. That guarantee was revealed to be conditional, transactional, perhaps gone, as an American administration treated its oldest allies as marks and its old adversary as a partner. European leaders, who had spent decades assuming the umbrella would always be there, confronted the vertiginous reality that it might not, that they had outsourced their existential security to a patron who no longer felt bound to provide it, and that they now had to build, at desperate speed and enormous cost, the defence they had assumed they would never need to build alone. The war in Ukraine reached its third anniversary this fortnight. The alliance that had opposed the invasion reached, perhaps, its end.

GERMANY

Voters turn right, and the far right doubles

Germany, Europe's largest economy and its anxious anchor, held an election on February 23 that put the mainstream right under Friedrich Merz first, months of coalition-building ahead of it but delivered a shock beneath the result: the far-right Alternative for Germany doubled its vote to around 20 per cent, its best result since the Second World War, becoming the second-largest party and confirming that the nationalist surge sweeping the West had reached deep into the German heartland. Merz, who will lead a fragile coalition, faces the task of governing a country economically stagnant, strategically exposed by the American retreat, and politically fracturing, at the worst possible moment for the continent he is meant to help lead.

IN BRIEF

A chainsaw for the state; a pope gravely ill; a new model

Elon Musk, wielding an actual chainsaw on stage at a conservative conference, celebrated his effort to slash the federal government, which has torn through agencies, fired tens of thousands of workers, and moved with a speed and disregard for law that the courts are only beginning to check. Pope Francis, 88, was hospitalised on February 14 with double pneumonia and was, by the Vatican's own grave account, in critical condition, fighting for his life. And the AI race pressed on beneath the geopolitics, Elon Musk's xAI releasing a new model, Grok 3, that it claimed rivalled the best of its competitors.

The Column

The first week of November, 1956

Europe's leaders came home from Munich saying the American guarantee has conditions after all. Britain and France were taught the same thing in a single week in 1956, in the middle of a war they had started at Suez, and the two of them drew opposite conclusions from one lesson.

On the evening of the twenty-sixth of July, 1956, in a square in Alexandria, Gamal Abdel Nasser announced to a vast crowd that Egypt was nationalising the Suez Canal Company, and as he spoke, Egyptian engineers were already moving into the canal offices, the speech itself carrying the codeword that sent them. London and Paris called it theft. Nasser reminded his audience what the canal had cost: it ran through Egyptian ground, dug by Egyptian labour, and tens of thousands of the labourers had died in the digging, while the revenues flowed for decades to shareholders in Europe. Anthony Eden, the British prime minister, decided within hours that Nasser had to be destroyed, and spent three months arranging it.

The arrangement was made in secret, in a villa at Sevres outside Paris, in late October. Israel's leaders were there, Ben-Gurion among them; France's ministers; and Britain's foreign secretary, Selwyn Lloyd, attending a meeting his government would deny for decades. The script agreed at Sevres had Israel invade Egypt's Sinai first, whereupon Britain and France, posing as neutral firemen, would order both sides away from the canal and then land, in the costume of peacekeepers, to take the waterway back. Eden was ashamed enough of the document to order the British copy destroyed. The plan ran on schedule: Israeli paratroops dropped into Sinai on the twenty-ninth of October, the ultimatum followed, British bombers struck Egyptian airfields on the thirty-first, and on the fifth and sixth of November allied troops took Port Said at the canal's mouth, at the cost of hundreds of Egyptian dead, most of them in that one town.

Then it stopped, within days of the first landing, and not because of anything Egypt did. Dwight Eisenhower, facing re-election that very week while Soviet tanks crushed the rising in Budapest, was incandescent: his two closest allies had lied to him, launched a colonial war behind his back, and handed Moscow a gift at the worst conceivable hour. He sent no ultimatum of his own. He went for the currency. Sterling came under selling pressure the Bank of England could not absorb, and when Harold Macmillan, the chancellor who had been the loudest voice for the war, asked Washington for support, the answer was that there would be no American loan and no help at the International Monetary Fund until Britain accepted a ceasefire without conditions, with oil for a Europe cut off by the blocked canal withheld for good measure. Macmillan brought the reserve figures to cabinet and changed sides in a sentence, earning the jibe that followed him for years, first in, first out. On the sixth of November, the day Americans re-elected Eisenhower, Britain halted the operation with its soldiers barely down the canal, and France, unwilling to stop and unable to continue alone, stopped with it. Eden flew to Jamaica to recover his health, and resigned in January.

The instructive part is not the fiasco but the divergence afterwards. Britain concluded: never again act apart from the Americans, and within months Macmillan, now prime minister, was in Bermuda repairing the relationship, the junior-partner settlement that has defined British policy ever since. France concluded the opposite: never again depend on the Americans, and set about acquiring its own deterrent and binding its neighbours into a European project conceived partly as insurance against abandonment. Same week, same humiliation, two lessons. And there was a third party to the lesson, the one Europeans rarely counted. Egypt kept its canal; Nasser stood taller across three continents; and the colonised world observed, with some satisfaction, that the two empires which had spent a century lecturing everyone else on order and law had been disciplined like debtors, by their own patron, through their own currency, inside a week.

The Europe that sat through the vice-president's lecture at Munich, and that watched its ally negotiate over Ukraine in Riyadh without a European in the room, is the Europe that chose, collectively, the British conclusion, and then built eighty years of security on the hope that November 1956 had been one angry president rather than a standing feature of the arrangement. The French conclusion sat on the shelf the whole time, costed and available. What Munich announced is that the exception was the rule, and the governments now scrambling to buy in a panic the independence they declined to build in calm do at least possess, in the file marked Suez, a seventy-year-old worked example of how the discipline operates and how few days it needs.

The Back Page

The second that lasted sixty years

Clint Hill died on February 21, at ninety-three, and for sixty-one of those years he carried a single second of time that most men would have given anything to be rid of. He was the Secret Service agent riding on the car behind the president's in Dallas on the twenty-second of November, 1963, and when the shots came he ran, caught the handhold of the moving limousine, and climbed up over the boot to shield Mrs Kennedy and her husband with his own body, and he was, by every account including the film the whole world has seen, as fast as a human being could possibly have been. It was not fast enough, because nothing could have been, and that was the sentence he served for the rest of his life. For decades he believed he had failed, said so, drank over it, withdrew from the world, told an interviewer in 1975 that he would carry the guilt to his grave and that he should have got there in time. It took him the better part of fifty years, and a return as an old man to the plaza in Dallas, to accept what everyone else had always been able to see, that a man cannot outrun a rifle, that arriving a second late when no human could have arrived sooner is not failure but the shape of being mortal in a world where the worst things happen faster than love can reach them. He spent his life guarding other people. In the end the person he had to learn to protect, and for a long time nearly could not, was himself.

A Dispatch Tale

The Dog Between the Hills

Two hills, two stubborn men, and one old dog who would not take sides.

On two hills divided by a shallow valley there lived two shepherds who agreed on almost nothing, not on the price of wool nor the weather nor whose grandfather had been the greater fool, and who would have told you, each on his own hill, that he needed no help from the other and never had. Between them, going freely up one slope and down the next, lived a single old dog, grey about the muzzle, who had long ago decided that both flocks were his to watch and could not be argued out of it.

For years this struck both men as faintly ridiculous. Each paid for half the dog's food and grumbled that he was feeding the other man's guardian, and each, in the small hours, took quiet comfort in the knowledge that while he slept the dog was somewhere on the ridge with one ear turned to his sheep and one to the dark.

The winter the wolves came down early, they came to the far hill first, and the dog was there, and he did what old dogs do, which is to make a great deal of noise and stand where the danger is until help arrives. The help that arrived was the other shepherd, stumbling down his own slope and up the far one in his nightshirt with a lantern and a stick, because he had heard the dog and understood, without a word needing to be said, that the dog's alarm on the far hill was his business too.

They lost no sheep that night, and said little about it after, and went on disagreeing about wool and weather for the rest of their lives. But neither of them ever again spoke of the dog as a shared expense, because both had learned the thing the valley had been trying to teach them for years: that a guardian who watches two hills at once is not a cost divided but a safety doubled, and that the neighbour you need no help from is the very one whose lantern you will be glad, one dark night, to see coming up your hill.

The Oracle

The fortnight read across the heavens, Western and Eastern. Find your sign; the Oracle is never wrong, and never responsible.

The Western Stars
Aries21 Mar to 19 Apr

Charge ahead. The wall, on inspection, was load-bearing, and is now your problem.

Taurus20 Apr to 20 May

Hold the line on the thermostat. It is the only war you are currently winning.

Gemini21 May to 20 Jun

You will win an argument with yourself and lose the rematch.

Cancer21 Jun to 22 Jul

Home calls. So does the parcel locker, more urgently.

Leo23 Jul to 22 Aug

You will rehearse a casual, off-the-cuff remark for forty minutes in front of the bathroom mirror.

Virgo23 Aug to 22 Sep

A friend asks for light feedback; you provide it annotated, cross-referenced, and entirely unrequested at that volume.

Libra23 Sep to 22 Oct

You see both sides of an argument and are promptly disliked by both, which seems, to you, entirely fair.

Scorpio23 Oct to 21 Nov

Someone wrongs you mildly; you say nothing and plan nothing, and that silence does all the heavy lifting.

Sagittarius22 Nov to 21 Dec

Restlessness strikes mid-sentence and you leave the conversation the way others leave a burning building.

Capricorn22 Dec to 19 Jan

Ambition whispers at 6am and you answer before it has finished the sentence, plan already laminated.

Aquarius20 Jan to 18 Feb

You will predict the future accurately and tell nobody, so as not to appear as though you cared.

Pisces19 Feb to 20 Mar

Offered an escape from a hard conversation, you take it, swimming off like a startled, poetic fish.

The Chinese Zodiac
Rat1996 · 2008 · 2020

A coin found behind the skirting board confirms your suspicion that you are the only sensible person alive.

Ox1997 · 2009 · 2021

The field does not plough itself, which is the only philosophy you have ever needed.

Tiger1998 · 2010 · 2022

You leap before looking and, against all counsel, the looking would not have helped.

Rabbit1999 · 2011 · 2023

You smooth over a dispute so thoroughly that both sides suspect you started it.

Dragon2000 · 2012 · 2024

The hoard of praise you guard is large; spend a little on someone else for once.

Snake2001 · 2013 · 2025

You renew yourself quietly this fortnight and let others discover the new you by accident.

Horse2002 · 2014 · 2026

You will bolt from a perfectly good arrangement the instant a gate is left ajar.

Goat2003 · 2015 · 2027

Two equally dreamy paths present themselves; you stand between them until both quietly close.

Monkey1992 · 2004 · 2016

You will reach for the shiny thing, secure it, and immediately begin coveting the next shiny thing.

Rooster1993 · 2005 · 2017

Vanity peaks splendidly this fortnight; the puddle you admire yourself in is, alas, shallow.

Dog1994 · 2006 · 2018

A quiet night unsettles you more than a loud one; you keep one ear on duty regardless.

Pig1995 · 2007 · 2019

You will host, feed, and forgive everyone, then quietly keep the last pastry for yourself.

The Vedic Rashis
MeshaMangal · 14 Apr

Courage is a debt Mars extends at interest. You borrowed boldly once; the ledger quietly comes due now.

VrishabhaShukra · 15 May

Venus sweetens every pleasure until it cloys. The lesson returning: enough is a number only the wise can name.

MithunaBudh · 15 Jun

Mercury splits your mind in two so neither half must bear the whole. Convenient, until a choice demands one.

KarkaChandra · 17 Jul

Chandra waxes, and your tenderness with it. Give it to the living; the Moon keeps poor accounts of the gone.

SimhaSurya · 17 Aug

Your light casts a shadow you keep forgetting to face. The lion's blind spot sits directly behind the mane.

KanyaBudh · 17 Sep

The wheel rewards the useful, not the flawless. Finish the imperfect good deed before polishing the perfect intention.

TulaShukra · 18 Oct

Shukra holds the scales and lets you discover that balance is motion, never rest. Adjust, again.

VrishchikaMangal · 17 Nov

What must die in you is already dying. Mars officiates; the cosmos sends no flowers, only room.

DhanuGuru · 16 Dec

A teacher arrives this fortnight wearing inconvenience. Guru rarely knocks when you are ready to answer.

MakaraShani · 15 Jan

You envy the swift. Saturn reminds you that what is raised in haste he visits later, with a bill.

KumbhaShani · 13 Feb

An unconventional idea arrives early, as yours do. The cosmos is patient; wait for the age to catch up.

MeenaGuru · 15 Mar

You forgive too easily and call it weakness. The ocean, forgiving every river, has never once felt small.

Small Ads

Notices, personals, and things lost or for sale, from in and around the works.

FOUND: a quiet corner of the open-plan office. Will trade for a door, any door.

RETIRED mainframe, 1987, still running payroll, seeks dignified successor. Must be patient and fluent in COBOL.

PERSONALS: lonely central banker seeks someone who believes the forward guidance. Discretion, and low interest, assured.

WANTED: the hour between two and three on Thursday back, promised to deep work and taken, without notice, by a sync.

FOR SALE: blockchain, lightly used, solution still looking for its problem. Open to offers in fiat.

NOTICE: the all-hands is cancelled. The hands have unionised and are now simply all.