Vol. I, No. 11
Covering 30 December 2024 - 12 January 2025
Monday, January 13, 2025
Late edition · A Relentless publication
All the fortnight that mattered, in technology and in the world, read next to what we were building at the time.❀
No notifications, no autoplay, just the fortnight.
LOS ANGELES

The second city of America burns, and the hydrants run dry

Wind-driven wildfires tore through Los Angeles this fortnight, incinerating whole neighbourhoods from Pacific Palisades to Altadena, killing dozens and destroying thousands of homes. Firefighters arrived to find the hydrants empty. A city that thought itself the future watched it burn.

Firestorms driven by hurricane-force winds swept across Los Angeles from January 7, destroying entire communities, killing at least 24 people, a toll certain to rise as the burned neighbourhoods were searched, and burning more than 12,000 structures in what will rank among the most destructive wildfires in American history. The Palisades fire consumed one of the wealthiest enclaves in the country; the Eaton fire obliterated much of Altadena, a historic middle-class community; and for days the nation watched, live, as one of its great cities burned block by block, the smoke visible from space, whole streets of homes reduced to ash and lone chimneys, the famous and the ordinary alike fleeing with what they could carry. The winds were so fierce that aircraft could not fly and the flames outran every effort to contain them.

And then came the detail that turned a natural disaster into an indictment: in the Palisades, as the fire raged, the fire hydrants ran dry. A water system built for structure fires, not for a wind-driven inferno consuming an entire district at once, was overwhelmed, its tanks drained, its pressure gone, leaving firefighters standing at dead hydrants as houses burned around them. A key reservoir had been offline for repairs. Officials will spend years apportioning blame, among the water system, the fire budget, the forestry practices, the climate that made the landscape a tinderbox, and the failure to clear it. But every one of those answers will be filed by a different office, and there is the deeper indictment: the fire arrived as one event, wind and fuel and water pressure and budget acting together, and it was met by a city that manages them as separate concerns in separate departments, each defensible on its own terms, none accountable for the whole. The catastrophe got in not through any single agency but through the unowned ground between them, which no budget line covers and nobody is paid to patrol.

AMERICA

A president-elect threatens allies, a sentence lands with no punishment, and Meta abandons the referee's chair

Donald Trump, days from returning to power, spent the fortnight issuing expansionist threats against allies, Greenland, the Panama Canal, Canada, that unsettled the entire Western order before he had taken the oath. He was formally sentenced in his New York criminal case on January 10 to an unconditional discharge, no punishment, preserving the historic conviction while sparing the incoming president any consequence. And in a telling capitulation, Meta announced on January 7 that it would end its independent fact-checking programme across Facebook and Instagram, replacing it with user-written "community notes," a clear bid by Mark Zuckerberg to align his company with the incoming administration's hostility to content moderation, and a retreat by one of the world's largest information platforms from any role in policing the truth of what it distributes.

IN BRIEF

Terror in New Orleans; a farewell for Carter; a ceasefire's fragile hope

An Army veteran inspired by Islamic State drove a truck into a New Year's crowd on Bourbon Street in New Orleans on January 1, killing 14, as, hours later and hundreds of miles away, a Cybertruck exploded outside a Trump hotel in Las Vegas, a grim double omen for the new year. The United States held a state funeral for Jimmy Carter on January 9, gathering all five living presidents in one pew, a rare tableau of a fractured country's leadership together. And negotiators pressed toward a Gaza ceasefire and hostage-release deal, the first real hope of a pause in a war now fifteen months old, as the incoming and outgoing American administrations, remarkably, worked in tandem to close it.

The Column

The referee leaves the field

Meta has abandoned fact-checking, and it will be cheered as a victory for free speech. It is something else: the largest information platform on Earth deciding that policing truth is no longer worth the trouble, at the moment truth is hardest to find.

Meta's decision to end its fact-checking programme has been framed, by the company and its admirers, as a triumph for free expression, a retreat from censorship, a return of judgment to the users. It is something quite different and considerably worse: the largest information distributor in human history deciding that the job of refereeing truth on its platforms is more trouble than it is worth, and walking off the field, at the very moment when the game has become most dangerous to leave unrefereed. And the free-speech argument for the move is not empty; the honest version of what Meta did is simply more troubling than the partisan one.

Here is the genuine dilemma, because pretending it does not exist is how people get this wrong. Fact-checking at the scale of Facebook is genuinely hard and genuinely fraught. The "referees," the fact-checking organisations, do make mistakes, do have blind spots, do sometimes label as false things that are merely contested, and a private company deciding what is true for billions of people is a real and legitimate worry, not a manufactured one. The case against the referee is not stupid. But notice what Meta actually did with that real dilemma: faced with the genuine difficulty of refereeing truth well, it chose not to referee at all, which is not a solution to the difficulty but a surrender of the responsibility, dressed up as a principled stand. "This is hard and we sometimes get it wrong, so we will stop trying" is not a defence of free speech. It is an abdication, and the fact that it happens to align perfectly with the incoming administration's wishes, and to save Meta a great deal of money and political grief, should make us suspicious of how principled it really is.

The deeper problem is timing, and it is why this move matters far beyond one company's policy desk. Meta is walking off the field at the exact moment the field has become most treacherous. We are entering the age of generative AI, of synthetic images and video and text indistinguishable from the real, of an information environment in which telling the true from the fabricated is about to become harder than at any point in human history. This is the moment when some mechanism for establishing what is true, however imperfect, matters most, and it is the moment the largest platform on Earth has chosen to abandon the effort. The referee is not leaving because the game got safe. The referee is leaving because the game got hard and dangerous and politically costly, which is when a referee is most needed, and "community notes," a system of users annotating each other, however well it works for some things, is not a referee; it is the crowd, and the crowd is the thing that most needs refereeing.

So we do not cheer this, and would ask anyone tempted to cheer it to look past the free-speech framing to the actual substance: a company that got rich by becoming the world's primary distributor of information has decided that it will take the money for distributing it and refuse the responsibility for whether any of it is true, at the dawn of the era when truth will be hardest to find. That is not a principled stand for open discourse. It is the referee pocketing the gate receipts and walking off the pitch as the match turns violent, and calling it a victory for the players. The players, all of us, are about to discover what a game with no referee, in the age of synthetic everything, actually feels like. We do not think we will enjoy it, and we do not think, when we are drowning in confident fabrication with no one even attempting to sort true from false, that we will remember it as the day free speech won.

The Back Page

Five in a pew

At Jimmy Carter's state funeral this fortnight, the cameras found a single image that said more than any eulogy: the five living presidents of the United States, seated together in the same pew at the National Cathedral. Biden and Trump, bitter enemies weeks from a hostile transfer of power. Obama and Trump, who have spent a decade as each other's foil, caught on camera in unexpected, easy conversation, Obama laughing at something Trump said, a moment the whole country puzzled over. Bush and Clinton, a Republican and a Democrat turned unlikely friends by the strange fraternity of the office. For a few minutes, in a church, mourning a man whose decency had transcended the partisanship that consumes them all, the five people who have held the most powerful job on Earth sat in a row, their enmities suspended by the older ritual of honouring a predecessor. It will not last; Trump's inauguration is days away, and the knives are out. But there was something in the tableau, in a fractured country whose leaders can barely be in the same room, of an older idea: that the office is larger than the person, that the men who hold it belong to a fellowship that outranks their quarrels, that even now, even here, some rituals still gather the enemies into one pew. Carter, who spent his life on just that kind of quiet, unfashionable decency, would have appreciated that his funeral, for a few minutes, made it visible. Then everyone went back out into the cold, and the country, to its war with itself.

The Funnies
This could have been an email.
There will be a follow-up meeting to discuss the length of this one.
The Oracle

The fortnight read across the heavens, Western and Eastern. Find your sign; the Oracle is never wrong, and never responsible.

The Western Stars
Aries21 Mar to 19 Apr

First to volunteer, first to regret: your hand shoots up before the question has fully landed.

Taurus20 Apr to 20 May

Comfort is your fortress; this week its walls repel a yoga class, a diet, and a well-meaning relative.

Gemini21 May to 20 Jun

Two minds, one deadline. Neither will volunteer.

Cancer21 Jun to 22 Jul

Home is where the heart is, and where the parcel was, according to the app, delivered.

Leo23 Jul to 22 Aug

You were born to lead, says the horoscope, which is also what it told everyone else.

Virgo23 Aug to 22 Sep

You will alphabetise something that did not ask to be.

Libra23 Sep to 22 Oct

Peace is yours this fortnight, pending one reply-all you can still prevent.

Scorpio23 Oct to 21 Nov

You will reveal nothing, learn everything, and leave the gathering knowing three people's passwords by vibe alone.

Sagittarius22 Nov to 21 Dec

Honesty is your gift, delivered this week unwrapped, unsolicited, and roughly two notches too loud.

Capricorn22 Dec to 19 Jan

You climb a ladder with great discipline and pause, near the top, to ask who leaned it against this wall.

Aquarius20 Jan to 18 Feb

The crowd goes left; you go right on principle, arrive nowhere interesting, and declare that the entire point.

Pisces19 Feb to 20 Mar

You start a diary of your dreams and lose it immediately, which is, you decide, deeply on brand.

The Chinese Zodiac
Rat1996 · 2008 · 2020

When the building floods, you will already know the one dry passage out; modesty forbids you mention it.

Ox1997 · 2009 · 2021

You plod toward a distant goal and arrive, long after the crowd has gone home disappointed.

Tiger1998 · 2010 · 2022

You will pounce on an opportunity that turns out to be a reflection, and land anyway, grandly.

Rabbit1999 · 2011 · 2023

Caution rewards you: the ledge others leapt from was, as you suspected, a ledge.

Dragon2000 · 2012 · 2024

Your grandeur is undimmed by the fact that the applause was for the person behind you.

Snake2001 · 2013 · 2025

One strike, well timed, settles a matter that shouting could not; you then vanish.

Horse2002 · 2014 · 2026

You bolt from a commitment at the first open gate and run somewhere identical.

Goat2003 · 2015 · 2027

Art pours out of you until someone asks what it is for, at which point it stops.

Monkey1992 · 2004 · 2016

A rival sets a trap; you take the bait, the trap, and the credit.

Rooster1993 · 2005 · 2017

You will announce the morning loudly and correctly to a household that did not request it.

Dog1994 · 2006 · 2018

Loyalty runs deep this fortnight, as does the worry that nobody else is worrying nearly enough.

Pig1995 · 2007 · 2019

Contentment finds you early and settles in, to the mild alarm of the more ambitious.

The Vedic Rashis
MeshaMangal · 14 Apr

Courage is cheap this cycle, patience the rarer coin. The stars note you have spent neither wisely.

VrishabhaShukra · 15 May

Venus rewards the patient gardener, not the hungry one. What you planted seasons ago is quietly ripening.

MithunaBudh · 15 Jun

Budh gifts you a clever tongue and two of everything else. Spend the words as if each carried karma, because each does.

KarkaChandra · 17 Jul

A feeling you drowned years ago floats back this cycle. The Moon returns what the heart only pretended to bury.

SimhaSurya · 17 Aug

Authority settles on you this cycle like a crown always slightly too warm. Wear it, do not sleep in it.

KanyaBudh · 17 Sep

The body sends a plain message this cycle. Analyse less, rest more; even Mercury takes a slower orbit sometimes.

TulaShukra · 18 Oct

Venus loves the beautiful compromise. Beware the one so lovely it quietly costs you the thing worth keeping.

VrishchikaMangal · 17 Nov

What you bury alive, the wheel exhumes. Mangal counsels: let it die properly, then there is nothing to dig up.

DhanuGuru · 16 Dec

The guru in your sky asks you to teach what you half know; teaching is how the cosmos makes you learn it.

MakaraShani · 15 Jan

Shani measures the mountain and your patience, finding both sufficient. Climb; the summit was never the point.

KumbhaShani · 13 Feb

You serve a future you will not inhabit. Saturn calls this dharma; the crowd calls it eccentric. Both are right.

MeenaGuru · 15 Mar

Surrender is not defeat. Guru teaches that the river reaches the sea precisely by ceasing to resist.

Small Ads

Notices, personals, and things lost or for sale, from in and around the works.

WANTED: one adult, any field, to attend the meeting on my behalf.

WANTED: quiet. Will pay. Apply to the open-plan office, loudly, as that is the only way.

WANTED: back the four hours lost to the all-hands. Reward offered, in more hours.

LOST: the plot, somewhere near the third pivot. Please return it to the nearest adult in the room.

LOST: institutional memory, last seen leaving with Dave. Dave also missing.

LOST: the thread. If found, please do not reply-all.