Vol. I, No. 8
Covering 18 November - 1 December 2024
Monday, December 2, 2024
Late edition · A Relentless publication
All the fortnight that mattered, in technology and in the world, read next to what we were building at the time.
Opinions are the writer's; the facts belong to everyone.
THE MIDDLE EAST

A ceasefire finally silences the guns in Lebanon, as Syria's frozen war suddenly thaws

After a year of escalation, Israel and Hezbollah agreed to stop fighting, a rare piece of good news. Days later, in a shock nobody predicted, rebels swept out of Syria's dormant civil war and seized a major city, and a map the region's powers had long since filed away began to move again.

A ceasefire between Israel and Hezbollah took hold on November 27, ending, at least for now, more than a year of fighting that had killed thousands in Lebanon, displaced over a million, and, in its final months, decapitated the militia and devastated its strongholds. The deal, brokered by the United States and France, requires Hezbollah to pull back from the border and Israel to withdraw over 60 days, and while few expect it to resolve the underlying enmity, it silenced the guns on one front of the region's war, a rare and genuine relief. In Gaza, however, the war ground on, the hostages still held, no equivalent deal in sight, and the suffering undiminished.

And then, in the last days of the fortnight, a shock: the Syrian civil war, frozen and half-forgotten for years, roared back to life as rebel forces launched a lightning offensive out of the northwest and seized Aleppo, the country's second city, in days, against a regime that had held its lines, with Russian aircraft and Iranian militias, since 2016. The suddenness stunned everyone. Bashar al-Assad's government found both patrons busy with other wars, Russia with Ukraine, Iran and Hezbollah with the wreckage Israel has made of their year, and a front the world had stopped watching was moving again within a week. Where it leads, no one knows, but the ledger of the region's alliances, who can still spare aircraft for whom, whose militias are already committed elsewhere, was being rewritten in real time, and Aleppo was its first new entry.

AMERICA

The transition takes shape, and it is a revolution in loyalists

Donald Trump's transition to power took shape this fortnight as a deliberate assault on the institutions he blames for constraining his first term. His cabinet and senior appointments, a parade of loyalists, disruptors and provocateurs chosen for their fealty and their hostility to the agencies they would run, signalled unmistakably that the second term will not repeat the first, in which establishment figures acted as guardrails. Some nominations were so incendiary they collapsed within days; others advanced. The message was consistent: the checks that held the first time, the officials who resisted, the norms that constrained, are to be removed, and a government reshaped to answer to one man's will.

IN BRIEF

A warrant for a leader; a bumper year for the machines; a founder's fortune

The International Criminal Court issued arrest warrants on November 21 for Israel's Prime Minister Netanyahu and its former defence minister, alongside a Hamas commander, over alleged war crimes in Gaza, an unprecedented step against the leader of a close Western ally that drew fury from Israel and Washington. Artificial-intelligence companies closed a frenzied year with a wave of new models and features, the pace of release relentless, even as the question of profit lingered. And the fortune of Elon Musk, now an intimate of the president-elect and tapped to lead a new government efficiency effort, swelled past $300 billion, the largest in history, as the political bet he had made paid off spectacularly.

The Column

The slowest instrument

Three arrest warrants have been signed in The Hague, one of them for the sitting prime minister of a Western ally. Whether such a document is a dead letter or a slow fuse is a question with honest evidence on both sides, and this column has tried and failed to settle it.

On November 21, while the region watched the ceasefire line in Lebanon, three judges of the International Criminal Court signed arrest warrants for Benjamin Netanyahu, for his former defence minister Yoav Gallant, and for the Hamas commander Mohammed Deif, a man Israel believes it killed in July. Put the politics down for a moment and consider the object itself. A warrant from this court is a few pages and a seal. It commands no army, no police, no bailiff. It obliges the 124 states that belong to the court to arrest the named men should they set foot on their soil, it obliges nobody else, and the named men choose where they set foot. I have spent the fortnight trying to work out what such a document actually is, and the honest report is that I do not know, because the two available answers each come with evidence I cannot dismiss.

The first answer says it is a dead letter. The court borrows its muscle from governments, and it needs that muscle most from the governments least willing to lend it. Vladimir Putin has been under one of these warrants since March 2023, for the deportation of Ukrainian children. In September he flew to Mongolia, a member state bound on paper to detain him, and was met at the steps of his aircraft with an honour guard and a red carpet, and departed on schedule; the court recorded the breach and could do no more than record it. Omar al-Bashir of Sudan travelled under warrant for a decade, member states among his hosts, and none of them ever handed him over. Neither Israel nor the United States recognises the court, and Washington's response to the new warrants ran from furious dismissal to talk of sanctioning the judges themselves. On this evidence, a warrant against a protected leader is a gesture wearing the costume of law.

The second answer says it is a slow fuse, and its evidence is just as concrete. Slobodan Milošević was indicted in May 1999 by the Yugoslavia tribunal, this court's elder sibling in the same city, while he was a serving head of state in the middle of a war, and the indictment was called a futility then in the same confident tones. Two years later he was in a cell in The Hague, delivered by his own successors, because the indictment had outlived his hold on power and had become, for the government that followed him, part of the price of rejoining the world. Charles Taylor was indicted in 2003, found exile and protection, and is serving fifty years in a British prison all the same. A warrant does not expire. The man it names ages; his patrons' interests shift; governments change underneath him; and in the meantime his lawyers begin vetting the layovers on every flight he takes, which is a small thing, and a permanent one.

What keeps me from choosing is that the record is too thin to carry either conclusion. Every man these courts have put in the dock had already lost power for other reasons, so there is no way to tell whether the warrants caused anything or merely attended it. Serbia surrendered Milošević with a European future to purchase; no comparable lever exists here. And the clocks are mismatched: the surrounding politics runs on days, while the instrument signed on November 21 runs on decades, so any verdict on it written this week, including this one, comes before the experiment has properly begun. I sat down expecting to argue myself into one of the two readings, and I have not managed it. The warrants exist now, filed where no government can unfile them, and I cannot tell you what they weigh. I can only tell you that everyone who claimed to know, in either direction, was guessing with more confidence than the evidence has earned.

The Back Page

Three hundred billion

Elon Musk's fortune passed $300 billion this fortnight, the largest personal fortune in the history of the human species, and it did so as a direct result of a political bet. Musk spent much of the year and a great deal of his money backing Donald Trump, appeared at his rallies, ran a get-out-the-vote operation, and has emerged, in the weeks since the election, as an intimate of the president-elect, tapped to lead a new effort to slash government spending, his companies' fortunes and his own now entwined with the state in a way no private businessman's have been in living memory. His electric-car company, his rockets, his satellites, his social network, his AI venture, all stand to benefit from an administration he helped elect and now helps staff. There is no precedent for it, a single individual, the richest who has ever lived, having bought his way to the inner circle of a government whose contracts, regulations and subsidies shape his empire. Whatever one thinks of the man, and few are neutral, the concentration is the story: of wealth, in one person, at a scale never before seen, and now of political power alongside it, the two fused. Concentration has been the defining fragility of the age, the single bank, the single supplier, the single point of failure, and the recent record, from failed lenders to a world halted by one bad software file, keeps proving it. Here is concentration of a different and newer kind: the fusion of the largest fortune ever assembled with the levers of the most powerful state on Earth, in one restless, unpredictable, unaccountable man. What could go wrong is a question the coming years will answer. That something might is the only safe prediction about a concentration that complete.

The Funnies
NEW NEWER NEWEST
By the time he finished the manual, it described an antique.
He has filed it with the others, under archaeology.
Small Ads

Notices, personals, and things lost or for sale, from in and around the works.

APOLOGY: to the sprint we called agile. We were, on reflection, simply out of breath.

LOST: one on-call pager, somewhere in a river, on purpose. No reward, no regret.

WANTED: data centre tenant who has seen the cooling bill and stayed anyway. Faint of heart need not apply.

PERSONALS: discreet venture capitalist seeks the next big thing, same as the last, but sooner.

NOTICE: we are not hiring, we are right-sizing. The right size, it transpires, is smaller than you.

FOR SALE: entire crypto portfolio, HODLed to the bitter end, now simply held. Will accept lunch.

The ink held, the deadline did not, and between them this edition was made.Set after hours by the Night Compositor